Trading professional seeking transition from brokerage to fund execution roles

I work as a derivatives broker with expertise in cross-commodity trading, particularly in agricultural sectors. My experience comes from working on a physical trading desk. Recently, I’ve been considering career opportunities on the buy-side, especially execution trading positions at commodity-focused investment funds.

I’m curious if anyone here has successfully made a similar career move from brokerage to fund execution? What technical skills and competencies do these buy-side roles typically require? I’m planning to learn programming and wondering whether Python would be a better choice than VBA for someone in my position.

Any insights would be valuable since I imagine the competition for these positions is quite intense. What steps should I take to make myself a stronger candidate for this transition?

Python for sure. Buy side execution is mostly about TCA and understanding flow impact.

Your ag desk experience helps since you already know the actual supply demand drivers.

Your derivatives background is a great start. Buy-side execution is all about order flow, market microstructure, and cost analysis. Ditch VBA and learn Python - that’s what funds actually use for data work, backtesting, and algos. Get comfortable with pandas, numpy, and basic stats libraries. Hit up industry events and connect with fund traders. Most good jobs never get posted publicly. Your cross-commodity experience is actually a huge advantage since most execution traders only know one asset class. Try smaller funds first - you’ll do everything and learn way faster.

Skip big funds and target commodity shops directly.

Python crushes VBA for buy side work. Funds want people who can run trade cost analysis and know how orders move markets.

Your physical trading background is actually an advantage - you get the underlying markets way better than execution traders who’ve only seen screens.

Hit up mid-sized commodity funds instead of the big names. They’ll give you real responsibility faster and won’t nitpick your credentials as much.

Made the same jump 3 years ago - metals desk to execution at a commodity fund. Interview was brutal. They hammered me on algos, transaction cost models, execution strategies I’d never touched on the sell side.

What saved me? Built a bunch of Python scripts before applying. Made tools for analyzing historical execution data, calculating TWAP vs VWAP performance, that kind of stuff. Shows you can actually code instead of just talking about it.

Physical trading experience was huge though. Fund PMs loved that I got storage costs, transport bottlenecks - all the real world stuff that screws with execution timing. Most buy side execution guys are pure quants who miss that.

Start networking now. Commodity fund world’s tiny and everyone knows everyone. Former clients who went buy side are your best way in.